< RFK Update Redux
Sycorax >

[Comments] (3) Deck-Building Wargame: I was talking to Pat about the hot new deck-building wargame A Few Acres Of Snow (great game title, BTW). I was at a conversational disadvantage since I've never played the game and didn't know anything about it other than "deck-building wargame". For discussion purposes I made up a game in my head that had nothing in common with the real game, and Pat said "that's totally wrong." BUT, I think the game I made up could be a really good game. All it requires is months of work and fine-tuning which I don't have time to do:

Picture a card-driven wargame like your Memoir '44. You have units on the board, and you draw cards that tell you which units you can move. Now picture Dominion, the original deck-building game, in which you buy cards that go into an endlessly recycled, ever-expanding deck. Now... imagine that your Dominion deck contains the orders for the units on your Memoir '44 board.

Now you have the war-torn chaos of Memoir '44, in which you can't fire your artillery because you don't have the card that lets you give the order, mitigated by the strategic buying of Dominion, with which you can choose to stock up on "fire the artillery" at the expense of other orders.

Units and orders are both for sale. Maybe orders are bought with "money" cards like Dominion, while units are put onto the board with special "deploy" cards. Maybe when you buy a unit you also get two or three different order cards for your deck. I don't know; months of work go here. But it would be a fun game, and hopefully someone's already done this, or will soon.

Bonus Mashup: spice up your Memoir '44 game by introducing the drafting mechanic from Seven Wonders. Pass two hands of seven cards back and forth, replenishing when you run out. Since this doesn't require months of work, Pat and I will actually be trying this, and I'll let you know how it goes.

Filed under:

Comments:

Posted by Benji York at Tue Oct 25 2011 13:57

This reminded me of a Carcassonne variation that crossed my mind the other day: instead of randomly drawing a tile on every turn, each player gets a private hand of, say, 5 tiles to play from. This would let you plan series of turns in advance and would be especially interesting during the endgame.

Posted by Leonard at Wed Oct 26 2011 12:11

I'm starting to think that any game with a "draw one" mechanic could be made more social by replacing it with a "draft from a set and swap" mechanic.

Posted by Ben Heaton at Thu Oct 27 2011 02:01

That's pretty much the game I imagined when someone described A Few Acres of Snow to me as a deck-building wargame. Now I'm going to need to check out what the actual game is.

Also, I keep meaning to introduce the "draft mechanics always improve games" principle to my Scrabble group.


[Main] [Edit]

Unless otherwise noted, all content licensed by Leonard Richardson
under a Creative Commons License.